I would like to move the guild online as well; unfortunately I can see several issues;
1. It becomes a chore to stay updated
2. Lack of incentive
2.a. Incentive is too harsh not to be online therefore it makes them resentful
2.b. Incentive is not enough not forcing people to be online
3. We move from a small casual guild to a larger guild requiring more management.
Just my thoughts.
Regards,
Exael